My Anthem

Monday, July 24, 2006

Joining the RACE!

My Merdeka Day wish for the impending 49th birthday of NegaraKU is to see our beloved Prime Minister Pak Lah do one symbolic act of unity -- Give a directive to all Government departments to DELETE with immediate effect the small column or space where any applicant has to fill up in official forms: RACE/KETURUNAN.

There is justicicatyion for NATIONALITY to distinguish between a Malaysian and foreigners.
BUT CLOSE TO HALF A CENTURY,
MALAYSIA MY NEGARAKU STILL WISHES ME
WHO HAS ALWAYS FROM BIRTH IN MAUBAU, N.S.
CONSIDERED MYSELF A MALAYSIAN -- nothing else --
TO STILL SPELL OUT MY ANCESTRAL BLOODLINE...


WHAT FOR?
So you will give me demerit or merit points?

From Day 1 of my Blogging, I have averred that the New Economic Policy -- slated for 20years from 1970 -- has served its original stated objectives, namely:

* To bridge the gap of the haves and haves-not;
** To disengage the identification of any ethnic group with particular occupations, service functions or professions.


We have largely achieved that.
I have called on the Government to replace the "divisive" NEP with NEEDS-BASED POLICIES AND PROGRAMMES, so that thopse in greatest need receive the maximum aid, and those well-to-do receive less or nothing at all.
What else can be more fair and sensible? You tell me if there is another better option!

(NO, not that PKR or Anwar Option! Mave SM and Helen have overdosed/zed on that madsin!) Just a wee, little bit of DDC, K!After one long week of abstinence, like S'X, ...self-censored, after reading Howsy's and Anak Merdeka's mind.


But by continuing the NEP -- and looks like perpetuating it until eternity
under the mysth that the 30% Bumiputra equity has not been attained -- I contend that
from 1990, NegaraKu has not progressed -- nay it has regressed! -- along the route to unity. The main stumbling block is the revival of the NEP, under various guises.

I said that as much and to similar effect to a certain "comrade" member who is a member of the National Unity Panel who invited my INPUT a year ago to address this issue. I posted my collated views expressed in various articles -- especially a series in conjunction with several civic-minded BBlogger frineds, across race and colour and creed, also across gender and greed -- we coordinated to mark Malaysia's 48th birthday.

Look around you -- assuming you stay at all these Taman-taman, and tyou still see BILLBOARDS at startegic locations promoting new house, condominium sales. Yes, even condos priced at above RM250,000 and what is staring at you?

DIFFERENTIATED HOUSE PRICES, with 7-15% discounts for Bumiputras.
Like an old record replaying, Desi says this is the MOST DIVISIVE
encounter we meet in routine daily living in Malaysia. WE ask, and
quite justified, if a BUMIPUTRA CAN AFFORD TO BUY A RM250,000 PROPERTY< WHY SHOULD HE BE GIVEN PREFERENTIAL TREAMENT.

I submit such Malaysians who have ALREADY ARRIVED -- be you blardy Chinoserie, Indiamen or Melayu, or Iban or Kadazan -- if your icnome capacity can accord you the capacity to but a quaerrter-million property, you should pay a SPECIAL GRATEFUL
CITIZEN TAX to go into a FUND FOR LOW-COST HOUSING to help the less-privileged fellow Malaysians.

Want to talk about scholarships?
Waarded to those from VVIP, well-connected, already well-to-do families?
OR to INGRATES -- ask Health Minister Datuk Dr CHUA SOI LEK,
who informed us that some RM100million spent on 70 Malaysians studying medicine in the UK who refused to come back to serve their scholarhsip bonds -- what's happening to these cases. OR HAS THE NUMBER DOUBLED?
We, the tax-payers, have a right to know.

Reading the following article in the New Sunday Times gave Desi a chance to re-visit the topic of ETHNIC RELATIONS. This of course followed the infamous UPM textbook produced in "three weeks" (has theat blardy GuinNURSE Buku Rekod-Rekoder alloted this buku a place o'lay?) that rightly so caught the nation's attention. Oh, the secondary act of the horde of 50 hooligans bullying seven fellow students ... is it the same notorious -- oops, take the word back, substitute, less than favourable" mention in the media the past week -- in case I'm accused of running down the whole campus fraternity whose alumni include some BIG WIGS, yes?


Sunday Interview: We still have room to find solutions
23 Jul 2006


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
He’s a soft-spoken man who has been given a big responsibility — getting Malaysians closer together. National Unity and Integration director-general Datuk Azman Amin Hassan, who has been in service for 30 years, speaks to ABDUL RAZAK AHMAD about the root causes of ethnic conflict in Malaysia.

Q: What’s the current state of unity and integration in this country ?

A: As someone whose job is to protect and enhance our unity and integration, I’d say that on a scale of zero to 10, Malaysia stands at 6.5. We don’t have planned racial conflicts. We feel safe to move about freely.

There’s also good co-operation between the races. But we need to do a lot more. We do have occasional cases of fighting, and because they occur between a Malay and an Indian, for example, they get classified as a "racial" incident. But if you look at the root cause, you’ll find that not all are caused by race or religion.


Q: If race and religion aren’t the root causes of ethnic incidents, what are?

A: Sometimes it’s the dissatisfaction of the poor. A rubber estate is cleared for a housing project. The residents are displaced. This creates pockets of discontent among these poor people. The resentment builds up.

And when a minor incident involving a person from another race happens, things explode. The root causes are mostly socioeconomic, or related to laws and calls to amend certain regulations that affect people of different faiths.


There are also grievances due to "demolition" of places of worship. Those affected say they can’t understand why they have to move for a housing project when their temple has been there for 20 years. These potential tensions exist in this country. But it’s important to note that we still have ample room to discuss and find solutions.


Q: Every minor quarrel seems to have the potential to explode. Is unity in Malaysia so fragile?

A: When I look at every incident, I find there are always early signs that we missed. After an incident, we tend to say the situation in this country is not good because very minor misunderstandings can still blow up so easily.

In truth, most of these incidents are retak menanti belah (cracks waiting to shatter the container). It’s like a fire. There’s the spark that starts the fire, and there are also the conditions that cause the spark.


Q: Can you give an example?

A: Take the Kampung Medan incident five years ago. The root cause was socioeconomic. The residents were promised new homes. They waited for years, but the homes were not completed. If you saw the conditions they lived in — houses with cement floors and zinc roofs, in a neighbourhood with a drug and prostitution problem — you’d have seen how the socioeconomic plight of the community connected to the whole episode.

The "spark" was a minor incident involving people from two races. One group acted, another reacted; the trouble spread. But the root cause and original grievance and dissatisfactions of the community were longstanding and deep-rooted.


Q: What struck you most about Kampung Medan?

A: I was then director of the Department’s Rukun Tetangga (RT) programme. I commuted from Subang Jaya to work using the KTM Komuter service. I passed Kampung Medan every day and I would observe the people who got on and off the station; I’d look at the area. Something was not quite right.

On the morning of March 8, 2001, I casually remarked to the director-general, Ainon Kuntum, that I suspected something could happen in Kampung Medan. We pulled out the file on Petaling Jaya. But we did not have much to go on: there was no RT programme in the area, no grassroots network reporting to us.


I got a call that very night from Ainon telling me that a terrible incident had happened in Kampung Medan. We felt utterly frustrated.

We had been promoting unity all this time — and this happened.

Ainon made some right and quick decisions in dispatching a team to the area quickly. And one of the first things done was to set up an RT. I was there every night. The first six nights I saw many families sleeping outside on the verandah. They were afraid that mobs would torch their houses. It took us quite a lot to persuade them to go inside.


But I realised things were going to be okay when the RT team, made up of Malays and Indians, said they were willing to patrol their neighbourhood. They were united and committed to keeping outsiders from coming to create more trouble in their neighbourhood. It was a relief, because we had other concerns at the time.

Q: You have witnessed the ravages of ethnic strife. But is it hard to convince the general public about the importance of an intangible thing like national unity?


A: Many people view incidents like Kampung Medan mainly as a quarrel between people of different races. Apart from that, unity isn’t really as important to many as economic indicators, for example.


I wish I could quantify the financial losses due to racial incidents.

If I can total the amount spent on hospital bills for the victims of Kampung Medan, the cost of deploying extra policemen, the amount of business lost in the area, and the number of foreign investors who cancelled plans to invest or pulled out, then I can say this is how much the Kampung Medan incident cost Malaysia.

The Fire and Rescue Department puts a ringgit estimate to damage caused by a fire. Why can’t we do the same for damage caused by incidents that threaten national unity? We’ve never quantified such damage before. It’s time we did.

Maybe, then, more people will open their eyes and appreciate how important unity really is.


Q: How important is the upcoming National Unity and Integration Action Plan?

A: It’s Malaysia’s first five-year unity plan. We were operating on annual plans and in some aspects we worked in isolation. Last year, for example, the department organised 35,000 specific activities geared towards national unity, involving the participation of three million people.

But even that’s not enough. Ministries like Education and Information have their own programmes, but there are still a lot of groups and parties out there that need to be roped in, including the private sector and non-governmental organisations.

The plan is a more systematic approach to national unity. It outlines what each sector, Ministry and agency can and should do in the next five years.



Q: How will progress be monitored?

A: I suppose we will become the policemen of national unity in Malaysia. We’ll be looking at whether a particular ministry is carrying out the plan and what its initiatives are.

The ministers will have to report to the Cabinet Committee on National Unity and Integration that will be set up. We’re also developing instruments to objectively measure unity, called a national unity index. A higher index number means that unity in a particular area is good. A lower figure means the opposite.


We need something concrete, because for many, unity is a very elusive thing. It’s so important, but not something you can hold in your hand.

DESIDERATA:

I have given two key points to the issue which I think lie at the centre of a national conundrum.
Today I wish to appeal to my EsteemedReaders, please share your views -- NegaraKU is yours too in all equality and Equity, don't let anyone bully you into thinking any less! -- on what the good Datuk Datuk Azman Amin Hassan, has spent a long weekend giving you his thoughts. You owe it to him and yourself, and future generation. Don't rely ion Desi as your Echo-Chamber-lah, sometimes Empty Vessels Maketh the Greatest Din.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

Any plans for Merdeka?! Heehee.

(:

Anonymous said...

I wish to join the RACE too!! hehe..

chong y l said...

kyels: Yes, ROIginally, the 3EYE Project I hinted at! Now Y&A johnleemk is doing the Limbo Rock, and Desi's sweating the Rock&Roller with Faith&Nicole.
Kyels has to get hold of Sabrina to come back SOON! My feree dental treats.:(

chong y l said...

xpyre: One salute, and big goblet of tehtarik+Ms Sunthi for a fantastic report on Art 11.

Dear ER, go surf xpred.textfiend.net after this, worth more than RM1.20-lah!

Xpyred, remmemberrr my 30%CONm.....!:)

Helen said...

Datuk Azman Amin Hassan made sense but the tricky part would be the monitoring and assessing the progress rate.

All races attend National Schools.. that's a good start. But,when it comes to the working world, the division is more obvious than ever. Think B, think garmen job.

If the garmen is serious about racial integration, open Putrajaya to all lar... Many other races too have people who stop at SPM.

Anonymous said...

(roll my eye), RACE? I want to join CASH. It just remind me the proverty elimination committee head that adacabra with the multi millions ringgit funds.

OTH, I think the cost and side effect of the ethnics "economy distribution" programme just too costly. When things need to go through "ethnic screening", it will create extra administration layer and cover up. I will not be suprised that those extra steps cost us as much as 5% of GDP annually.

With the 5% GDP missing on the way, I think it is enough to set up a funding/consultation system similar to grameen bank. In addition, the country also lack of intelligent body to study environment economy, which allow locals to develop best economy structure by the given geographical environment.

Maverick SM said...

The nation is directionless and leadership is entirely lacking. What is going on is basically, think when it goes wrong and find an excuse after that.

At the same time, call for more committees to be set up and more discussions of what not to discuss.

We are driving to the kennels.

Arena Green said...

Did you say DIN?

DIN Merican seems to give a pertinent hint of how bad the situation seems to be now for Pak Lah. Looks like our PM is fighting the forces within and this is BAD NEWS for all of us.

chong y l said...

helen:
Yes, the common people can come up with "sensible" solutions to these "ethnic relations" problems BUT they set up committees comprising PhDs, Masters etc and you know what? They come up with Solutions that need some sub-committees to mull over which can be implemented, which are not and then one smartalec will say "Let's KIV!" until after General Elections, and the cycle is repeated. Circular world, eh?

I'm NOT adding more ideas except what I see as TWO PRIMARY ACTIONS that the PM can conisder -- one immediately, the other soon, and the rest will fall into place. Befopre that can happen, I guess we have to say many I.S.As.:)

chong y l said...

moo_t:

Methinks you're TOO generous to put the seeapage at 5% of GDP. My guesstimate is more at 30% -- you know the COMMON SINGALONG -- the 30% conmission, markup?

I have chatted with Contractors for big ticket projects -- by the time a JOB is done, it has gone through maybe 10 SUB-contractors? Can you imagine the MARK-UOPS by every sub-sub-con? Finally the Rakyat are CON-nned all the way, a RM500million project is ballo0ned to RM1billion, like the workings of a Pyramid or MLM scheme. Singapore is smart -- they banned ALL puramid schemes, true, semi-, CON- -- but we prefer to learn from African countries...Can yyou follow Desi, say one more I>S>Amen before I sign off.

chong y l said...

mave: directionless eh?
Art thou trained as a PILOT?
I may be able to find a Pilot pen in my old almari.

Mave, serious mode: THAT'S WHY WE NEED TO REPLACE THE STATUS QUO.
But between Pak Lah and the old regime, I think Mr Nice Guy is trying to "do something-lah"! :)
Hey, Rome is not built in 24!:(

chong y l said...

anak merdeka: NOT that "Din" you encounter at BakriMusa's...I won't say more except I think Din writes from a perspective beholden to Dr Mahathior for whom he's worked with ... That's not to be held against him, but he lets EXTRANEOUS factors get in the way of discourse, imho after some engagement lah!

I'd rather now look forawrd to "Din, Dine and playing DDCode?" on board SS Virgo with fellow bloggers...

Maverick SM said...

Are u saying serious thinking? About what?

Seriously, what is good for Malaysia is that: the govt must consist of a strong opposition (which is multi-racial). DAP cannot fit this bill. PAS can be chauvinistic. KeAdiLan may fit the bill but they are currently manned by UMNO rejects and lack intellectuals all round.

The best option: Dr. M forms a new party along the ideology enunciated by Onn Jaafar, with the Malays as the leader and the Chinese and Indian as his deputy. Possibly, he needs the Dayaks and Iban and Kadazans in order to form a strong opposition. Only this man can mount a strong challenge against the BN's strength.

That's my Merdeka prayer.

Anonymous said...

From the economy side, the biggest bleeding, MAS and Proton is under weed control stage now. Rather "fast" if you look at pass 10 years status quo on MAS and Proton. YTL just too bold to "test the water", I am guessing who is giving him the idea/instructions to do that.

Some wild speculation before the 49th Negaraku.

Bio-diversity project will not be possible without knowledge, I will expect some gradual change on education and knowledge "sharing and distributions". WiMax is a good idea to "warn" some taikun and to gain new allies,investor. East Malaysia is sparse enough to carried out some of this project.

Bet the e-government will continue in different and greater magnitute. TunM e-government is actually a good tools to isolate out "deficiency" problem, but dragged by MoF and other ministry to hide the trakcs. Something for MSC perhaps.

No cabinet reshuffle will happen, but we will see TunM little horse being isolated out for most of 9MP plan. For a cheap shot, some of the minister make Tun for them to retire(I am still laughing at those bogus immunity by the title).

Revival of double track project , where TunMCo will be given portion of it. I'll not be surprised if some oil palm tycoon "willingly" to take part of the financing.

A committe to set up to "upgrade" PDRM. More funds to upgrade police hardware and software.

A new round of negotiation over the bridge(next year?). New term like "Private initiated funding" is included in the negotiation.

Perhaps a mass transit system to join JB and SG.

Not sure all will happens within 2 years. Hope he will no get his hand won't get itchy over bleeding edge legacy megaproject.

Anonymous said...

Maverick, you are asking too much.

I think TunM talk is what keep him alive than rotting at home quietly. Setting up opposition? You are asking doom for 85years old. Did anyone notice TunM looks better when he talk recently? Compare to the pale face before he passing the seat?

Maybe Pak Lah should find some candidates to keep TunM occupied(no, not moNSTer).

chong y l said...

mave:

As a nation's pilot, Dr Mahathir did not seize the day to "revoltionalise" Malaysian politics to non-racist plane, now you advocate he leads "The best option: Dr. M forms a new party along the ideology enunciated by Onn Jaafar..." That's a mighty 22 years LATE!

At 82/83, compared with Anwat at 59, my bet is still on PKR +Anwar despite UMNO rejects, warts and all (to fill the intellectual "gap", ppl like you jowsy and Desi can make a CONtribution, small of BIG 100B+100s! Seriously sharing, I've "re-written" several of my Blog posts for Suara Keadilan to use, and they had ... gratis of course. For fellow Msians who wish to become a millionaire by 30, pls don't join tghe Oppo, maybe Eat, Drink and Be Merry, yes. They have a leader who was once a billionaire-at-27 to (MIS)lead you!

Mave, Dr Mahathir is GOOD as far as we are conmcenrned in opening up UMNO's cans of worms, but hoping he'd do an Onn Jaafar, it's l;ike wishing PAS drop its MOON-shine!:(

But let's keep exploring our Options ... hopefully over tehtarik with a Group of 7 bloggers?

chong y l said...

moo_t:

I generally agree with your Menu of what's on Pak Lah's plate -- just pray hard while UMNO money-politics is always an albatross on his neck, the PM can check the degree of seepage -- cut down from 50% to 20% for a start. As with any free-market system, (let's say, even IOF PKR takes over, with DAP playing secondary role in Gomen...) there will be "room" for"seepage". As long such 'wastage" is within controllable limits (I would say NOT above 20%), NegaraKu can still attain V2020, but time's running out.
Pray doubly hard that Najib is NOT the one after Pak Lah; hence somehow, sopmewhere, "Anwar" must make his APpearnce, after "reformation" of the mind post 6 years of incarceration, including SOLITARY CONFINEMENT.

So Mave -- hey, where Xpyre? -- pls revert with further comments, esp responding to Moo_t?

Me, I've to rush to do today.s Post, give Howsy some pub'icSiti!:(