Singapore, to Down Under, then back again
Like a cycle or a ferris wheel
Hey, when the vacancy of a hangman crops up in Sin-land
A dissentin' Ozzie came aboard to give da helpin' hand?
Singapore sacks its hangman
From: Reuters From correspondents in Singapore
November 27, 2005
SINGAPORE has sacked its long-serving hangman, less than a week before the scheduled execution of Australian drug smuggler Tuong Van Nguyen.
"They called me a few days ago and said I don't have to hang Nguyen and that I don't have to work anymore," Chief executioner Darshan Singh said.
"I think they (the prison authorities) must be mad after seeing my pictures in the newspapers," Mr Singh said following reports he had been sacked after being identified by the Australian media.
Media reports said a new executioner was expected to be flown into Singapore this week to carry out the December 2 hanging of 25-year-old Nguyen, who was sentenced to death for carrying 396g of heroin while in transit at the island-nation's airport.
Mr Singh, a 74-year-old ethnic Indian, was reported in the Australian media to have conducted more than 850 hangings in his 50-year career. The reports said Mr Singh had wanted to retire, but the search for a replacement was unsuccessful.
Despite repeated pleas from Australia to reconsider clemency for the former salesman, Singapore has stood firm on its decision, saying that Nguyen Tuong Van was caught with enough heroin "for 26,000 doses" and that the Government would not allow Singapore to be used as a transit for illicit drugs.
Singapore has one of the world's toughest drug laws (Similar to Malaysia's).
Laws enacted in 1975 stipulate death by hanging for anyone aged 18 or over convicted of carrying more than 15 grams of heroin, 30 grams of cocaine, 500 grams of cannabis or 250 grams of methamphetamines.
Amnesty International said in a 2004 report that about 420 people had been hanged in Singapore since 1991, mostly for drug trafficking, giving the city-state of 4.2 million people the highest execution rate in the world relative to population.
I was working at the Australian High Commission in Kuala Lumpur during the truial of Kevin Barlow and Brian Chambers; both of them were also sent to the gallows in July 1986, despite widespread calls -- from Australian government and individuals -- for clemency. "DADAH IS DEATH" banners prominently greet overseas arrivals, so to plead "ignorance" is no defence.
And until the law is changed in the august Houses of Parliament in Southeast Asian countries, Australians and other "westren" peoples and their governments have to educate their peoples "When inRome, Do as the Romans do" applies.
The law is the law
As a Prime Minister John Howard did the necessary -- via the diplomatic channel, appealinmg for Nguyen's plea for clemency, which had been rejected by the Singapore President, on advice of the Singapore government.
Just as in the case of Barlow and Chambers, it would have been well nigh a "miracle" to believe the Head of State would grant clemency -- commuting the death by hanging sentence to life imprisonment.
The way some of Aussie politicians -- past and present -- tried to bring in "extraneous" factors to pressure the Singapore government, would, IMHO, have the opposite effect -- the noose around Nguyen;s neck would be tightened. No one responds kindly to neighbour's threats; seek benevolence in neighbourly threads.
Clemency grounds of aoppeal must rest on extraordinary factors -- medical condition like an IQ befitting a moron, extenuating circumstances considered from an average human's eye-lens. Nguyen's "reason" that he was carryiong drugs to save his brother's indebtyedness was not only counter-productive -- it reinforces the intent of the law to prevent a trafficker to those ill-gotten and quick bucks, at the expense of thousands of (young, innocent) lives -- mostly Aussies in Nguyen's case.
Maybe Singh's "sacking" is a temporary relief. I hope that "enthusiastic" aussie's offer to replace Singh would not be accepted. I also pray the Malaysian hangman's services would not be called upon.
Who knows, Nguyen's as well as his sympathisers' prayers, could be answered.
If no human comes forth to fill the Hangman's vacancy, Nguyen cam continue to hope. And hope must surely be with silents prayers of tears and repentance for a "wrongful" act.
IMPORTANT POSTSCRIPT:
*The United States of America is soon going to execute its 1,000th deathrow prisoner. An AP report datelined NEW YORK, carried by The Star, November 25, 2005 stated that (this week)ROBIN LOVITT is likely to earn the macabre distinction of being the 1,000th prisoner put to death since the US widely reintated capital punishment in 1976.
Lovuitt, 41, was convicted of fatally stabbing a man with a pair of scissors during a 1998 pool hall robbery in Virginia.
Will all those Aussies who yell "Stop the Death Penalty" at the Singapore government or any other Asian governments please lodge their protest at the nearest embassy? I'm holding my breath...
**Back home, there is a group of "young persons" who either carry a death wish, or are bloody fools; they openly taunt the Police with their drug habits and experimentations, also giving detailed information on the "safe use" of these banned rugs. Normally I leave such nincompoops alone --- but blogosphere is also a new medium of reach, and other YOUNGPERSONS shopuld also be cautioned lest they get carried away with their naivety and ignorance, then regret when the long arm of the law catches up with them.
Hey, deathwishers, citing grounds that such drugs are always available,if one is intent on getting the, and that other websites (quoting Google.com as one...)also carry such information on drug use is defence of the lowest IQ-occupant. Just because other countries tolerate certain modes of behaviour does not mean tghey are legal or proper. By publicly confessing you're doing drugs, you're giving these people enough rope to hang thee by the tallest tree in the county. Or are you vying for BolehLand's Braveheart Awards?
Well, if people wish to jump off the highest Twin Towers in da world, who is another Blogger to caution ftheir foolhardiness. But just don't influence your Younger Bros&Sis to go along, okay! They also like to shoot the messengers, don't they?
PPS: just to reassure thee that English standards in many newsrooms worldwide do NOT differ much in their deterioration -- down to the point where their jobs are not jeopardised.
"*The newspaper editor for the UNC* school newspaper
announces that there's enough money in the budget to
install a newsroom chandelier. The reporters huddle
and send a spokesman to say they're against it.
"Against it? Why?" the editor asks.
"First," the reporter says, "no one on the staff can spell
'chandelier' well enough to put it on an order form. Second,
I don't believe that anybody here can play one if we had it.
And third, if you got that much money, we think you should
get a hanging light instead, to brighten up the office!*"
mGf on a cloudy day, then stormy for two hours here in SS -- Welcome to the 4th estate slowly being absorbed into the real one. Just Desi's opinion, not Howsy's!
Don't shoot me, I'm not the messenger, I'm only a passenger! Dr Howdy's real culprit!
25 comments:
Interesting
The ozzie media stated Mr Singh was sacked ,but yet today said no no he wasn't .
It has been stated at the 11th hr ,
Nguyen Tuong Van may be granted
clemency..
I must say for the past several weeks
the media has drenched us with stories relating to Nguyen Tuong Van
Any ozzie that goes to Asia and carries drugs and states they don't know the laws of that land .couldn't blame Oz for not telling them.
We have commercials on every drug n it's affects , you could ask my nine yr old and he would know what he has learnt from tv n school.
I guess there could be ppl that think all countries , have the same laws in relation to drugs .
But like you said abide by the laws of the land ,where ever one is,,,,
cheerz
Laws of Sin-land have no colour grey; it's either black or white, sad to say; as such, 'hope' is only a cliche !
Hi, desiderata-ylchong. Greetings from a new reader across the causeway; will be back more often henceforth.
hi sweets! welcome back!
yes, i've followed the Oz media a bit..and i realised that it's somewhat a little bit..biased..
even followed the columns at SMH (sydney morning herald) and some even called for a boycott for Sg products!
how can that be?! when Sg controls Optus.. and not sure if they still hold Qantas?
Sg is a major player in the economical battlefield..boycotting them is like asking for death!
and funny thing is Ms H.Clark also joins the league of asking for clemency.. =P
Oh well.. don't know what to say..
Desi: at least this is a better distraction from the MSian politics which are getting more and more bodoh as the days go by...
Me? Shake my head-LAH
sweets:
people of all colours and countries share a common religioon of the heart -- we bleed when we are in pain.
yes, at death;s row -- that's extreme pain, extreme bleeding
my msg to YoungOnes everywhere:
enhjoy every moment that you breAthe
don't suffer it for a momentary gain
Agony, permamnet pain
That's the death penalty for Dadah
Momentary ecstasy for some, extremme idiocy
and some Adults mislead
I pray for my kids.
sweets-- smile for me as a child
and all will be well
for a long while
S-m-i-l-e back to thee:)
jpsc:
welcome thee with a tehtarik
if drunk well it lifts thee up
so that you'll come back for more
we'll chat, and smile together
you from sin-land, sweets from DU
me Boleh-lah,
on our commonness:)
sab: you got on das boat as sweets and our "new" guest from sin-land were rowing hard.
envy thee -- feeding on my charkeowteoy -- jaga dat waist-line; i wanted to say grapevine!
yes, let's once a while get outa msian landscape, so depressing tho i try my best to look at Da Sunrise...sweets, you're holding Him back at the sunset DU(h)!
Cheers, raise a piping cold terhtarik to every4 of us.now. See I steal can add 2 and 2.
Hi Sabby
Yeah the ozy media has played a frenzy with it all.
Don't get me wrong me, i care n feel for complete strangers in their darkest hour.
But part of me feels the ones left behind may suffer more and there is not justice in taking away another persons life.
Some ppl are being silly boycott sg
pfft it's the media and i am with optus and yes i know it's sg owned
would i change now way , actually
i will be buying my sons mobile n connecting with optus for him.
Actually Sabby a major resort near here ( on and Island ) belongs to Sgs , as does the Gold Coast .
Well i guess for now at least Michelle Leslie is getting a break from media backlash.
If only Desi had a forum hmm i might add one to my blog bcoz im addicted to the forums lately tsk tsk.
What stands out for me is that any literal interpretation of the laws would't really work, because each case needs to be look in its specific context, as some ccriminal offenders might be victims of circumstances.
Anyay, slightly off tangent, there was this movie which I havent but still want to watch called "Maria Full of Grace" about how this woman out of the desperation was 'forced' to become a drug trafficker.
(Why don't Malaysia screen more independent and arthouse movies?)
*shakes head like sab*
Not enough people are aware that even those who don't traffic drugs are taking a big chance visiting Singapore. Drug smugglers often bribe baggage officials to let them stash their drugs in some poor unsuspecting person's luggage, with plans of someone in Singapore collecting the luggage *after* it has cleared customs. Since Singapore's judicial system puts the defendent at burden of proving innocence, someone caught with drugs in their bags is at great risk of getting hanged, even if they are not drug smugglers. There have been several cases where people ultimately hanged did not appear to be actual drug smugglers. In one case, a couple traveling with their kid was caught, and eventually the couple was hanged despite pleas that the drugs were planted. I remember reading that the couple had to contact family members to arrange foster care for their kid.
sweets:
the Oz politicians and Msian politikus share lots in common -- most lack common sense.
I'd bettter not elaborate -- too much curry on white lice without my tehtarik doesn't taste gooda at all! Send me some rut bir and CON BF eh?
yan:
second your views, well put, and I dare not elaborater (add or subtract...)
not becos of too much curry:)
...can't say it badder!:(
BUTT
some people, YoungOnes included, will open their eys ONLY after the rope has been lassoed around their neckties!
PS to Yan:
Thanks to pointer on overcome "US Time Zone" difficulty,
BUTT2
some timelines threw my entries out of sync!
So how?
Blame the press-lah!
Desi also can sjoot the "mess"engers!
Must go practise
at sjooting lange:(:(
ah dreamer not i. coming out of da dream:
welcome your sympathetic look at the situation;
but Law in general looks at the general case -- on specific cases, too bad, unless you have a million bucks!
But for every "one" poor innocent nailed, many of the guilty bast.... cases (drug traffickers NO?) get away scot free. I hear the going rate is nothing less than SE7EN-figure-ah, my fave number!
Gooday, some Oz say: Good-ie! Sorry for the fun-pun, it's 70% intended. The other 30% was swiped by da loyar buluk!
PS to dreamI.:
can share Maria with me when you're finished with her?
Nothin knotty figured here -- voyeurs are not welcome to add fuel to fire -- too many foires going around and Pak Lah the Bomba Chief is engaged!
dear Anonymous whoever you are:
thanks for sharing.
yes, TRAVELLERS have to be always vigilant on their luggage.
*Never, ever, agree to take on some "stranger's" extra baggae!
** Donn't lave your bags UNattended even for a fleeting seconds -- these idiots have flee-ing flying feet, like da plane!
*** Reminder to all incoming travellers at KLIA- AP: DADAH is DEATH!:(
Socially, exaggeration is often whimsical. But when a government dramatically inflates numbers to help justify a death sentence, the integrity of both the trial and its governing body becomes questionable. In this case, the government is Singapore, the trial was for Van Tuong Nguyen, and the bloated number is 26,000.
Press from around the world quotes Abdullah Tarmugi, the Speaker of Singapore Parliament, in writing about the potential consequences of Van's actions, "almost 400 grams of pure heroin, enough for more than 26,000 doses."
But how was 26,000 doses (or "hits") derived?
It turns out that what constitutes a hit of heroin is not an easy thing to count. There are dozens of factors to consider; contact your local Needle Exchange for a comprehensive list. However, after collecting statistics from over a dozen sources (including police reports, narcotics web sites, health information, and workers from needle exchanges), the number of hits from a gram of pure heroin averages out to little more than 14.
Van Tuong Nguyen trafficked 396.2 grams of heroin into Singapore. This is approximately 5,600 doses.
The numbers 5,600 and 26,000 are obviously incongruous, as are reports that 400 grams of heroin would "ruin 26,000 lives". In fact, 400 grams of heroin would not come close to ruining even 5,600 lives. Rather, the heroin would most likely supply people already abusing it. With a little more research, we can estimate how many lives would be adversely affected by 400 grams of heroin during one year:
As many as 67, and as few as 6.
Van Tuong Nguyen would not have sent 26,000 people to their deaths from 400 grams of heroin. Nor would the lives of 26,000 people have been ruined. Far more likely is that six people would get a year's worth of hits. And for this he was executed?
Call it dreadful, call it dense, call it incomprehensible ... but do not call it justice.
dave:
welcome thee with a tehtarik, our usual traduition for a 1st timer!
my take here is not about Capital Punishment -- pros & cons, but your views are noted.
Suffice to say even if the Sin(g) govt EXAGHGERATES the numbers, look at its rationale -- prventying the drugs reaching the strets and making victims of youths!
I don;t care for the numbers -- whether it's ONLY ONE or by the thousands -- the runner and his BIG BOSS have palayed a role in enabbling the chain of death to the YoungOnes. I'm just looking at Da Rationale.
Tghis writer is tyrained in media and the sciences.I would like to dissect discussions in an objective manner.
I'd still say I can understand Singapore's, Malaysia's laws. Even the US is about to execcute its 1,000th death row prisoner.
"The law is the law." Until you can influence the electors to remove Capital Punishment from Sin-Land, I'm happy they are implementing the law with no double standards.
Let's no lose ourselves in the woods withough seeeing the forest for its cover and use. Don't lose thyself being a maryr shouting protests to save one man's neck; I've seen many alleged 'traffickers" get away cos they could enagede lawyers with their millionms.
dave: where do you think theyir millions came from?
PS: if you're a family man, or have siblings, just think ( a possibility, tho remore in probability...) that he/she becomes a drug addict at King's Cross or at Chow Kit, Jalan Alor ... I had seen addicts at "close hand" -- and it's no fun extrapolating how thier family memebrs feel seeing their child/teenage in "withdrawal".
Gooday. Let's converse sum more ...we have time, but sometimes, time is robbed off the YoungOnes. How tragic...
to ALL mGf ER:
ER is for EsteemedReaders, sumtimes XsteAmedRiddles! no-lah, just kdding meself:(
I visted "dave" my latest Reader at his Blog --WoW is the word if if you're inclined towards unmderstand the physical world. But Quantum Entanglement is set out in very layman's language -- go have a looka, esp Young&Articulate Ones, older ones also-can-lah, I know you just got a dose of Nerve Growth Factor and feel a decade or2 yuounger, Rite?!
Pls donate some on way out -- trying to raise that RM20m. M is for million, not like dat one Billionaire=at-27 and he preaches Eat, Drink and Be Mad! Sorry, M is 4Merry!
Hi,
Thanks for the welcome.
My brother's life was ruined by drugs. Had I the ability, I would have swapped him for Van without a second's hesitation. Van deserved to live.
My cousin's life was ruined by drugs, as well. She was much more like a sister to me than my brother was a brother.
I've seen alcohol ruin the lives of many. I've seen marijuana turn a human mind to mush over a few decades.
In other words, I'm not a stranger to what drugs do. Abusing drugs, is a vile way to spend your life. But it's a choice everyone is allowed to make for themselves.
Yet to hang someone for their first time transporting drugs is ghastly, despicable, intolerable, compassionless, and inhumane.
I say it's time for the world to execute capital punishment. Rehabilitate, don't decapitate.
dave:
welcome again -- it's a pleasure in reading your views well argued. I appreciate your "pro-life" no matter what case -- as thou put it "executite capital punishment"...
May i refer you to Sat's post comment by JPSC (from sing-land)who also presnted a good case for what the sing and many other SEA countries are doing -- enforcing a seemingly "barbaric" punishment to protect the larger community.
Looking at it (perverse may be!) -- the Sin gont might have done OZland a "favour" in preventing the drugs from being peddled at King's Cross -- taking finally how many lives? Even if "one" life was lost from the trafficker's money-motivated act, whose life would be "more precious" to preserve, Nguyen or VICTIM X, who could be a dear one to any family?
I can appreciate both points of view -- let's weigh them carefully and no so easily label dissenters as "barbaric" -- yes, the act of haging to death might be barbaric, never describe the Sing govt as such. The Sing govt was elected by Singaporean electors -- we finally get the govt we desrve...Amen?:(
Socially, exaggeration is often whimsical. But when a government dramatically inflates numbers to help justify a death sentence, the integrity of both the trial and its governing body becomes questionable. In this case, the government is Singapore, the trial was for Van Tuong Nguyen, and the bloated number is 26,000.
Press from around the world quotes Abdullah Tarmugi, the Speaker of Singapore Parliament, in writing about the potential consequences of Van's actions, "almost 400 grams of pure heroin, enough for more than 26,000 doses."
But how was 26,000 doses (or "hits") derived?
It turns out that what constitutes a hit of heroin is not an easy thing to count. There are dozens of factors to consider; contact your local Needle Exchange for a comprehensive list. However, after collecting statistics from over a dozen sources (including police reports, narcotics web sites, health information, and workers from needle exchanges), the number of hits from a gram of pure heroin averages out to little more than 14.
Van Tuong Nguyen trafficked 396.2 grams of heroin into Singapore. This is approximately 5,600 doses.
The numbers 5,600 and 26,000 are obviously incongruous, as are reports that 400 grams of heroin would "ruin 26,000 lives". In fact, 400 grams of heroin would not come close to ruining even 5,600 lives. Rather, the heroin would most likely supply people already abusing it. With a little more research, we can estimate how many lives would be adversely affected by 400 grams of heroin during one year:
As many as 67, and as few as 6.
Van Tuong Nguyen would not have sent 26,000 people to their deaths from 400 grams of heroin. Nor would the lives of 26,000 people have been ruined. Far more likely is that six people would get a year's worth of hits. And for this he was executed?
Call it dreadful, call it dense, call it incomprehensible ... but do not call it justice.
can i get more info?
Hi desider a, I was just blog surfing and found you! Wow, I really like this one.
It’s such a pleasure to read your post …. Interesting! I was over at another site
looking at Virtual Pbx
and they didn't go into as much detail as you, but nonetheless interesting.
Hi Friend! You have a great blog over here!
Please accept my compliments and wishes for your happiness and success!
If you have a moment, please take a look at my a's restaurant and music cafe site.
Have a great day!
Post a Comment